Introduction
During a recent SAP EWM go-live, our client successfully deployed a warehouse template at a pilot site. The rollout went smoothly, with minimal issues and a stable operational setup.
However, during preparation for subsequent rollouts, a warehouse-specific requirement surfaced: two resources that look identical in SAP EWM, but differ in real-life access capabilities.
The challenge was clear. We needed a solution that:
- Fits into the existing SAP EWM template
- Avoids disruptive system changes
- Does not impact daily warehouse operations
This article explains the problem, the two possible solutions we evaluated, and why one approach proved to be the best fit.
The challenge: identical resources, different access ranges
The client operates two warehouse resources that:
- Belong to the same resource type
- Are assigned to the same resource group
- Share the same physical and technical characteristics
Yet in practice:
- Resource Y can access certain warehouse locations
- Resource X must be restricted from those locations
The key requirement was to ensure that warehouse tasks meant for Resource Y are never assigned to Resource X, despite both being configured similarly in SAP EWM.
While deviating from the template was allowed, changes had to be minimal and controlled, due to the high business impact of warehouse operations.
Two possible solutions in SAP EWM
We designed and evaluated two configuration options, each with distinct implications for template governance, monitoring, and maintenance.
Option 1: Separate activity area and queue for Resource Y
The first approach introduces a dedicated activity area for the locations that only Resource Y can access. From this activity area, a separate queue is derived.
How it works
- Locations exclusive to Resource Y are assigned to a new activity area
- A dedicated queue is created for that activity area
- The queue is linked to the resource group of Resource Y
- Tasks in that queue are assigned only to Resource Y
Advantages
- Clear task assignment: Only Resource Y receives relevant warehouse tasks
- Queue sequencing can be fully controlled
- Easy monitoring and traceability
- Transparent workload overview
- Business can assign qualified operators to the correct resource and queue
- Fully in scope of the SAP EWM template
Disadvantages
- Requires an additional activity area within the same storage type
- Can lead to queue multiplication if overused
Option 2: Using Bin Access Type
The second option introduces Bin Access Type, which represents a new process in the SAP EWM template.
What is required
To make Bin Access Type work, the following is needed:
- Configuration
- Define resource type
- Define Bin Access Type
- Assign resource type to Bin Access Type
- Master data maintenance
- Assign the Bin Access Type to all relevant storage bins accessible by Resource Y
Advantages
- No need for a separate activity area
- Avoids queue multiplication
Disadvantages
- Difficult monitoring and traceability
- Limited workload visibility
- Process is out of scope for the existing EWM template
- Every resource type and bin requires a Bin Access Type
- Leads to extensive master data maintenance
Final decision and conclusion
After evaluating both options, we selected Option 1: separate activity areas and queues.
This approach:
- Ensures clear monitoring and workload transparency
- Uses concepts already familiar to the business
- Avoids introducing a new process into the SAP EWM template
- Fully meets the access restriction requirement with minimal system changes
Most importantly, it solves the business problem without compromising template integrity or operational stability.
Are you facing warehouse-specific exceptions that don’t fit neatly into your SAP EWM template?
👉 Talk to our SAP EWM experts to explore pragmatic, template-friendly solutions that keep your warehouse running smoothly.